Start Mortgages DAC v Cussen & Anor [2021] IEHC
531
The High Court has dismissed an appeal against a Circuit Court
order for possession on the basis that the defendant's case
consisted of "wide-ranging" arguments that relied upon
archaic legislation deemed to "make no sense as a matter
of Irish law".
Background
The defendants, who executed a mortgage over their property by
way of security for a loan facility on 13 June 2007, defaulted in
making payment of the monthly principal and interest from 21 May
2011 and, since 2017, had made no repayments whatsoever.
In their defence, Mr. Justice Barrett observed that the
defendants made "strange assertions" relating,
amongst other things, to their living status, claiming that they
are a "living man & living woman" who are
not "things to be salvaged". The Judge described
the approach of the defendants as "wanting in
sense" and a "form of legal nonsense"
having no relevance to the enforcement of debts under Irish
law.