The Supreme Court, in Delaney v The Personal Injuries
Assessment Board, the Judicial Council, Ireland and the Attorney
General [2024] IESC10, has upheld the legality of the personal
injury guidelines adopted by the Judicial Council on 06 March 2021
(‘Guidelines'). However, a further
finding by the court that the power given to the Judicial Council
to make guidelines pursuant to section 7(2)g Judicial Council Act
2019 (‘2019 Act') is unconstitutional
in its present form means that any further changes to the
Guidelines will require legislation by the Oireachtas.
Background
In April 2019, the appellant suffered injuries to her leg
following a trip and fall on a public footpath. An application for
assessment was made to the Personal Injuries Assessment Board
(‘PIAB') on 04 June 2019. At the time
of the accident, the Book of Quantum was used to assess damages for
injuries. However, when PIAB made its assessment on 14 May 2021, it
applied the Guidelines, which were, by