Determining the fair market value (FMV) of unquoted shares may
prove to be challenging for companies owing to choose the valuation
method. There have been multiple rulings by the Income Tax
Appellate Tribunal (the "ITAT") wherein
the methodology adopted by the company for the valuation has been
rejected on the grounds of being non-substantial. However, few
rulings have also been in favour of Companies where the ITAT has
squashed the argument of the Assessing Officer (the
"AO") stating that the tax authorities
can scrutinise the valuation report to the extent of finding any
arithmetical mistakes and not compel a taxpayer to choose the
method of valuation.
Despite Valuation practice being prevalent since the last six
decades in India, there is no specific guidance on the same and the
debate continues pertaining to the method to be followed.