INTRODUCTION
1.1 The evidentiary value of a Tax Residency Certificate
("TRC") as sufficient proof of tax
residency for the purposes of claiming benefits under a Double
Taxation Avoidance Agreement ("DTAA")
has been a subject of prolonged judicial and legislative debate in
India. Historically, Indian courts, most notably inUnion of
India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan,accorded significant sanctity to
a TRC issued by the competent authority of the treaty partner
country. A valid TRC was generally treated as sufficient evidence
to establish tax residence and, consequently, eligibility to claim
treaty benefits.
1.2 The historical development of the law relating to TRC and
the associated litigation was discussed by us in the article titled
"TRC – A Conclusive Proof of Residence?"[1]