The Bombay High Court passed a significant judgment in December
2009, which virtually denies foreign law firms entry into India on
the basis of the existing laws.
The Division Bench of the High Court, comprising of Chief
Justice Swatanter Kumar (As he then was. Currently, Supreme Court
Judge) and Justice J.P. Devadhar, in the matter of Lawyers
Collective v. Chadbourne and Park and Others, held against the
right of foreign law firms Ashurst (UK), Chadbourne and Parke
Associates (US) and White and Case (US) to set up offices in India.
The Court, inter-alia held that the words 'practising the
profession of law' under Section 29 of the Advocates Act, 1961
include giving legal advice in non-litigious matters. As per
Section 29 of the Advocates Act, 'advocates' are the only
recognized class of persons entitled to practice law in India.
However, it was alleged that these firms, although comprising
foreign nationals (not advocates), were providing consultancy legal
services