The Apex court's decision of December 14, 2017 in the case
of Toyota Jidosha Kabushiki Kaisha v Prius Auto Industries Ltd
& Ors (Civil Appeal Nos. 5375-5377 of 2017) affirming the
decision of the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court confirms the
new trend of applying the principle of 'territoriality'
over the 'universality' doctrine in the case of a passing
off action. In this case, the plaintiff (Toyota) was unable to
prove the existence of goodwill and trans-border reputation at the
relevant point in time in India for its mark PRIUS and had to lose
the case.
Keeping in mind the 'within India' picture, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India noticed that though the
plaintiff had used the mark PRIUS first in the world in 1997 and
gained certain amount of publicity since then across the world in
relation thereto, it was able to use the mark in India only in 2010
and had filed an application for its registration in 2009 on a
"proposed to be used" basis. Whereas, the