Third Circuit holds using Westlaw headnotes to train AI is not fair use
ROSS Intelligence, a now-defunct AI platform designed for lawyers, used 2,243 Westlaw headnotes to train its legal research platform. ROSS’s platform was “not a generative AI, meaning it would not create any new expression; it would only return text passages from preexisting judicial opinions.” But the district court rejected that fair use defense, finding that ROSS directly infringed Thomson Reuters’s copyrights in the headnotes. On appeal, ROSS argued that the headnotes lacked sufficient originality and reasserted its fair-use defense.
The Third Circuit affirmed partial summary judgment against Ross. The court held that Thomson Reuters’s creative decisions in drafting Westlaw headnotes demonstrated enough “creative spark” to satisfy originality. As for fair use, the court found that commercial use of the headnotes was “minimally transformative, at best,” because ROSS used the headnotes for the same