1. Key takeaways
Proportionality, flexibility, fairness, and equity are
criterions for exercising discretion on admission of subsequent
application to amend the patent
In exercising its discretion pursuant to R. 30.2 RoP, the court
assesses whether an admission of a subsequent application to amend
the patent complies with the principles of proportionality,
flexibility, fairness, and equity.
Substantial and specific reasoning required for
admission of subsequent application to amend patent
If a subsequent application to amend the patent is submitted
with the rejoinder brief, the reasoning must indicate which aspects
of the adversary party's submission in the reply are actually
new, how they relate to the amendments made in the auxiliary
requests, and how the amendments made in the auxiliary requests
relate to specific arguments of the adversary.