1. Key takeaways
A preliminary objection may also be deferred to the main proceedings by the panel, not only by the judge-rapporteur
The Court of Appeal clarifies that a decision under R. 20.2 RoP to deal with a preliminary objection in the main proceedings is not reserved to the judge-rapporteur alone. Where the matter has been referred to the panel, the panel may itself decide that the objection should be addressed together with the merits. The Court thus reads R. 20.2 RoP in the broader framework of the UPC's case-management rules rather than as conferring an exclusive power on the judge-rapporteur.
The Court of First Instance has broad case-management discretion to defer a preliminary objection, and that discretion was not exceeded here