On 5 October 2023 the European Court of Justice (ECJ) published
its decision in the case C-505/22 (Deco Proteste – Editores
Lda) concerning the VAT treatment of giving the gifts in return for
the first subscription to the company's magazine.
The referring court asked whether giving such gifts fell within
the concept of a "supply of goods for consideration" or
constituted a transaction separate from the subscription
transaction and, therefore, must be regarded as a disposal of goods
free of charge.
Facts of the case
Deco Proteste – Editores (the Company) publishes and sells
periodicals on subscription. As a part of a promotional campaign to
attract new customers, the Company gave new magazine subscribers a
gift (with the unitary value below EUR 50) upon the first monthly
subscription payment. As there was no minimum subscription period,
customers could keep the gift after the first payment and then
cancel the subscription.