In the 2023 Summary of Intellectual Property Court Judgments by
the Supreme People's Court, a range of cases were carefully
chosen to shed light on the assessment of "further
limitation" amendments in patent enforcement proceedings.
While these summaries offer valuable insights, some areas still
remain unclear. "Further limitation" refers to the act of
narrowing a patent's scope by introducing additional technical
features from other claims. This article aims to explore the legal
framework surrounding such amendments, drawing from trial
precedents dating back to 2017.
Ⅰ. Acceptance of "Further Limitation"
Amendments Across Independent Claims
The practice of limiting technical features across independent
claims, known as "further limitation" amendments, leads
to the formation of new solutions. However, challenges arise during
invalidation proceedings, such as incorporating one or more
technical features from one independent claim into another
independent claim.