In an administrative trademark invalidation dispute between the
plaintiff Fresh Company and the defendant CNIPA and the third party
Qiong Luo, the Beijing Intellectual Property Court held that the
Disputed Mark violated Article 30, Article 31 and Article 32 of
the 2013 Trademark Law. The CNIPA's
decision shall be revoked and the CNIPA shall make a new
ruling.

The first issue is whether the Disputed Mark filed by the third
party violates Articles 30 and 31 of the 2013 Trademark
Law. The court found that the Disputed Mark consists of the
English letters "Freshfragrance". according to the
general English cognition level of Chinese consumers, it is easy to
read it as two parts: "Fresh" and "fragrance"
of which the "Fresh" part is the same as the Cited Marks
1 and 4 in letter composition. It is also identical with the
distinctive part of Cited Marks 2 and 3. It is similar in
pronunciation to the Cited Mark 5. The Disputed Mark constitute as
an identical mark with all