The Tax Court has in recent years demonstrated a willingness to
use cost awards to control the parties' conduct. This includes
awarding lump-sum amounts, which may depart markedly from the
"tariff" amounts described in Tariff B of Schedule II of
the Tax Court's General Procedure Rules. Further, the
Court has wrestled with the weight – if any – that the
parties' conduct prior to an appeal should carry in respect of
a cost award.
In Martin v. The Queen (2013 TCC 38), the taxpayer successfully
challenged a section 160 assessment in respect of certain amounts
paid to her by her spouse. There was evidence the auditor had
deliberately misled the taxpayer during an audit, and the taxpayer
had spent considerable time and money enduring the audit and
objection process before her ultimate success in the Tax Court.