Just as there is nominal GDP and real GDP1, there is
political fairness and integrity and real fairness and integrity.
In his Eighth Action Plan, formerly known as a "budget",
the Minister from Whitby, Ontario has done an admirable job of
dealing with fairness and integrity within a political
framework.
However, before getting to the Minister's Plan, please allow
us to muse a little on what a real fairness and integrity budget
might look like. Consider a budget that we would expect to see if
the Minister had started the day reflecting on the thoughts of Jack
Mintz2: The small business deduction would be
eliminated, saving $3 billion per year3. The GST rate
would be increased to, say, 10% ($28 billion per year)4
and its base would be broadened considerably to tax 80% of
consumption instead of the current base which comprises 48% of
consumption5, in particular, to include food (add $36
billion at the new rate of 10%). This would be combined with
extensive credits to