In its 5-4 decision in an appeal from a motion for summary
judgment, the Supreme Court of Canada has arguably strengthened
property rights in Canada.
On October 21, 2022, the Supreme Court clarified the test on
constructive taking in the case of Annapolis Group Inc. v.
Halifax Regional Municipality1. This decision will
be of interest to clients dealing with development or other
applications before local governments and regulators.
In this case, the developer, Annapolis, had engaged in a land
banking exercise. Annapolis amassed a significant landholding, with
the intention of developing its property in the future. The Halifax
Regional Municipality ("Halifax") passed a restrictive
zoning and planning regime that effectively prevented
Annapolis' development. The ostensible purpose of Halifax's
zoning was to ensure that the land could be used for park purposes.
This raised a question about whether the land had effectively been
expropriated by the municipality.