In Lipson
v. Cassels Brock & Blackwell LLP, Justice Perell
revisited the scope of examinations for discovery in class action
proceedings. Perell J. held that as a general rule, where
there will be individual issues trials after the common issues
trial, a representative plaintiff being examined for discovery in
advance of the common issues trial is required to answer questions
relevant to both the common issues trial and the representative
plaintiff's individual issues. However, the representative
plaintiff is not required to answer questions relevant only to
other class members' individual issues.
Background
The plaintiff in this class action sued lawyers at Cassels Brock
& Blackwell (Cassels) in respect of a legal opinion that
Cassels provided to the Canadian Athletic Advisors in 2000 about
the tax consequences under the Income Tax Act of participating in a
Timeshare Donation Program. Pursuant to the strategy,
taxpayers would donate both cash and resort