Arbitration can offer businesses speed, flexibility, and finality when resolving commercial disputes. However, that finality comes with an important trade-off: once an award is made, the opportunities to appeal are limited.
A recent Alberta Court of King’s Bench decision highlights two practical considerations for businesses using arbitration clauses. The wording of the arbitration agreement can determine which issues may be appealed, and procedural concerns are difficult to appeal, particularly when such concerns were not raised during the arbitration.
In Medicine Hat (City) v. Fieldcore Service Solutions Canada Company, the Alberta Court of King’s Bench (the “Court”) dismissed Medicine Hat’s (the “City”) appeal of an arbitration award relating to liability for a damaged gas turbine.1 This decision reaffirms that courts: (i) will not interfere with an arbitrator’s procedural rulings absent “manifest unfairness”; and (ii) the scope of a party’s appeal rights is limited by the