In SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29, the Supreme Court of Canada clarified the consequences of intentionally destroying relevant evidence. It was the Court’s first significant consideration of spoliation of evidence since St. Louis v. The Queen in 1896. The decision reconciles inconsistent approaches to assessing damages where evidence has been spoliated, providing guidance for all litigators. For insurers, it also reinforces the importance of early preservation requests and documented disposal decisions.
Background and Litigation History
SS&C supplied securities-pricing data to the Bank of New York Mellon (BNY) under a licence agreement. After discovering unauthorized sharing, SS&C demanded preservation of records showing how the data had been used. BNY refused. At the damages phase, the trial judge declined to decide whether an independent tort of spoliation applied but drew adverse inferences from BNY’s failure to preserve and produce