The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal has confirmed that the Supreme
Court of Canada's decision in Orphan Well
Association v. Grant Thornton Ltd., 2019 SCC 5
[Redwater], applies in Saskatchewan. The Court of Appeal
also affirmed that orders made in failed proceedings in Alberta
under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement
Act (CCCA) did not have effect in subsequent
receivership proceedings in Saskatchewan.
In Eye Hill (Rural Municipality) v. Saskatchewan
(Energy and Resources), 2023 SKCA 120, the Court of Appeal
considered a claim by several Saskatchewan municipalities (the
Rural Municipalities) for proceeds in the receivership of Bow River
Energy Ltd. (Bow River), an oil and gas company with holdings in
both Alberta and Saskatchewan. The Rural Municipalities claimed
that unpaid property taxes owed to them should take precedence over
the Ministry of Energy and Resources' claim for abandonment
and reclamation obligations.