The Supreme Court of Canada's recent decision
in Nelson (City) v Marchi, revisits the
issue of municipal liability for negligence and determining when
core policy immunity applies. Specifically, the Supreme Court
determined whether the City of Nelson's snow removal policy was
a core policy, immune from negligence liability.
The City of Nelson was plowing and sanding streets after a heavy
snowfall in accordance with its snow clearing and removal policies
and practices. While clearing the snow, City employees plowed snow
to the top of parking spaces, making a continuous snowbank at the
curb which separated the parking stalls from the sidewalk.
The Plaintiff was a driver who parked in one of the parking
stalls and attempted to access a business on the other side of the
snowbank. While crossing the snowbank, the Plaintiff seriously
injured her leg. The Plaintiff sued the City for negligence and the
parties agreed that she suffered $1 million in damages.