On 7 October 2026, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (the “Court”) ordered the removal of an arbitrator from an ongoing construction arbitration in Atkinsréalis Construction (Pacific) Inc v GIP Construction Ontario East Ltd (“Atkinsréalis v GIP”). The Court held that the arbitrator’s prepared, adversarial questioning of the applicant’s two principal witnesses created a reasonable apprehension of bias, despite his undisputed good faith, construction expertise and the parties’ acceptance of a more inquisitorial approach.1
The decision illustrates the limits of procedural flexibility in arbitration. An arbitrator may participate actively and ask questions for proper purposes, but must preserve the appearance of neutral adjudication. No actual bias was alleged, and the Court expressly accepted the arbitrator’s sincere intention to perform his role properly. The decisive question concerned how his conduct would appear to an informed, reasonable observer.2