In T&S Transportation Systems Inc. v Bendix Commercial Vehicle Systems LLC, 2026 BCSC 1942, the British Columbia Supreme Court dismissed a product liability action for want of prosecution after approximately 14 years had elapsed since the underlying incident. Although the Court found that critical evidence had been intentionally destroyed, it declined to dismiss the action on the alternative basis of spoliation.
The decision provides an important reminder that the loss of evidence may be fatal to an action even where there is no intention to interfere with the litigation.
Background
The action arose from a January 2012 fire involving a commercial truck travelling from Toronto to Vancouver. The plaintiff alleged that defects in the design or manufacture of the truck or its braking system caused the fire.