In Rhebergen v Creston Veterinary Clinic Ltd., 2014 BCCA 97, a majority of the BC Court of
Appeal refused to relieve the plaintiff of the burden of the
restrictive covenant she had assumed in an associate agreement
between herself and the veterinarian clinic that employed her.
The covenant did not restrict her post-employment conduct but
required her to pay a specified amount if she set up a practice in
an area within 25 miles of the clinic that had previously employed
her. The amount was reduced each year over a 3-year period. The
lower court found that the covenant was in restraint of trade,
ambiguous and unenforceable.
The Court of Appeal agreed that the covenant was a restraint of
trade, in that it burdened the plaintiff with financial
consequences that she would not otherwise have had for engaging in
post-employment competition. The clause was not a penalty however;
it was compensation for the costs incurred by the clinic in
training the plaintiff. The majority