An important lesson is to be learned from BHP Coal Pty Ltd
and Ors v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG and Ors [2008]
QSC 141
Engineers are often called on to inspect works and are usually
obliged to provide a certificate to prove it. The BHP Coal case
highlights the importance of ensuring that engineers carrying out
inspections gain access to all parts of the machinery (not just the
convenient parts) and, in the event that access is impossible, this
must be communicated at the time of inspection, and carefully
documented in the inspection report.
The Goonyella Riverside Mine (Mine) used a
bucket wheel excavator (BWE) designed and
manufactured by O & K Orenstein (O&K) for
18 years until it suddenly collapsed due to a fracture in its
central tower. Some time previously when the BWE required repair an
O&K employee suggested the addition of lengths of steel, called
stiffeners, be welded onto the main tower of the BWE. The cracking
which led to the ultimate collapse of the