In our
September legal updates, we reported on a decision of the
Western Australia Court of Appeal, Pravenkav Group Pty Ltd v
Diploma Construction (WA) Pty Ltd. In that case, a company
which was resisting a statutory demand described an offsetting
claim in very broad terms, which was nonetheless held to be
sufficient for the Court to set aside the demand. We suggested that
the decision made it significantly easier to establish off-setting
claims, particularly in circumstances where they were difficult to
describe or quantify.
Another recent decision of the Western Australian Supreme Court
is a useful reminder that, if the recipient of a statutory demand
manages to convince a Court that a statutory demand should be set
aside on the basis of a weak offsetting claim, there are still
tactics that a creditor can use to prevent the statutory demand
procedure from being a waste of time.