The concept of "reasonable management action" arises
both in relation to workers compensation claims for psychological
injury (including claims concerning stress and anxiety), and in
relation to bullying claims in the Fair Work Commission. Reasonable
management action, carried out in a reasonable manner, may be a
defence to these claims.
What is reasonable will vary depending on the circumstances.
Here are some examples:
Worker sacked for obesity posing a workplace
risk
BHP Coal sacked a supervisor who weighed 160kg because medical
assessments indicated he couldn't perform some workplace tasks
safely because of his weight. The supervisor made a claim for
stress and depression resulting from the dismissal. Before
terminating his employment, the supervisor had been absent for
nearly two years on stress leave, during which BHP argued that it
made significant efforts to try to get him to return to work,
including regular contact, counselling, and