Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 18 JUNE 2010

Legal Update - Inspector Hamilton v John Holland Pty Ltd

On Friday 4 June 2010, the Full Bench of the NSW Industrial Relations Commission (IRC) handed down the first judgment in New South Wales which raised a Kirk argument. It was argued that the IRC did not have jurisdiction to hear the charges laid against the Defendant as defects in the Application for Order did not allow the Defendant to identify the charges against it.

AustraliaEmployment and HR
Michael Tooma (Formerly With Norton Rose Fulbright Australia)
Michael Tooma (Formerly With Norton Rose Fulbright Australia)
Barry Sherriff (Formerly With Norton Rose Fulbright Australia)
Barry Sherriff (Formerly With Norton Rose Fulbright Australia)
Author LinkedIn connections

Introduction

On Friday 4 June 2010, the Full Bench of the NSW Industrial Relations Commission (IRC) handed down the first judgment in New South Wales which raised a Kirk argument. It was argued that the IRC did not have jurisdiction to hear the charges laid against the Defendant as defects in the Application for Order did not allow the Defendant to identify the charges against it.

The Full Bench held that it does not matter; where or, in what form or, in which category the required elements of a charge appear as long as the Defendant is informed in the Application of the specific case brought against them.

The case provides an important clarification of the law in NSW and provides useful guidance as to how charges should be framed by Prosecutors.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from