Tocade and Comcare [2018] AATA 3863.
Key Points:
- Ms Tocade suffered an aggravation of pre-existing arthritis in
the neck at a work function in 1984.
- Comcare paid compensation for some 33 years before ceasing
payments.
Background:
Ms Tocade was an employee of the Department of Defence. On 6
January 1984, Ms Tocade was attending a work-related function. She
stepped backwards into a landing bay, fell down striking her head
and flexing her head forwards.
X-rays were taken of Ms Tocade's spine, which revealed
arthritis that had been present for quite some time. The
Commonwealth began to pay workers' compensation to Ms Tocade on
the basis that the fall had aggravated her pre-existing
spondylosis. Compensation was paid for 33 years until 29 May 2017,
when Comcare determined it was no longer liable to pay compensation
for medical expenses and incapacity. Ms Tocade brought proceedings
seeking review of this decision. She was 82 years old at the time
of the