The Halliburton case has the potential to have far reaching
consequences for securities lawsuits. If the Court overturns the
fraud-on-the-market presumption, class certification would be
exceedingly difficult for securities plaintiffs. As a result,
individual plaintiffs without large, provable damages would likely
have to resort to other theories of liability.9 Such a decision
would also result in case management issues for defendants. For
example, defendants would have to worry about seriatim lawsuits
(instead of just opt-out lawsuits) until the end of the limitations
period.
If, on the other hand, the Court does not overturn the
fraud-on-the-market presumption but allows defendants to rebut it,
class certification litigation will become more complex; defendants
will have a new tool to defeat securities classes and plaintiffs
will have a new hurdle to moving forward. Regardless, the
Court's decision should make next year a very interesting one
for the securities bar.