Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 24 APRIL 2025

When Arbitrators Use AI: LaPaglia v. Valve And The Boundaries Of Adjudication

Aceris Law
Aceris Law
Contributor
Aceris Law

Aceris Law

Aceris Law is a leading boutique international arbitration law firm. It provides the...

View firm profile
Explore more from Aceris Law

As artificial intelligence ("AI") tools become increasingly integrated into legal practice, their use by arbitrators is no longer a theoretical possibility but a practical reality.

United StatesTechnology

As artificial intelligence ("AI") tools become increasingly integrated into legal practice, their use by arbitrators is no longer a theoretical possibility but a practical reality. From drafting procedural orders to organising evidence or even assisting in the preparation of awards, AI offers the promise of greater efficiency, consistency, and cost-effectiveness. But what happens when that efficiency comes at the cost of human judgment?

A recent case filed in a U.S. federal court, LaPaglia v. Valve Corp., raises precisely this question. The claimant has petitioned to vacate an arbitral award on the grounds that the arbitrator allegedly relied on AI to such an extent that he "outsourced his adjudicative role."1 While the outcome of the case remains uncertain, it presents an ideal starting point for examining the limits of AI use in arbitration and the legal and ethical responsibilities that come with it.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from