A search warrant is not required for law enforcement to use pen
registers to record the IP addresses visited by a criminal suspect,
a federal appeals court recently held. This follows a 1979 Supreme
Court case, Smith v. Maryland, which
held that warrants were not required to use pen registers to record
the telephone numbers dialed by criminal suspects on landline
telephones. A pen register is a surveillance device that captures
phone numbers dialed from a specific phone line.
United States v. Soybel
was set in motion by a series of cyberattacks faced by W.W.
Grainger, Inc. in 2016. Grainger, an industrial supplies provider,
was able to pinpoint the apartment building of a disgruntled former
employee, Edward Soybel, as the source of the attacks. To confirm
that the attacks came from Soybel's apartment unit in
particular, the FBI applied for, and was granted, an order under
the Pen Register Act, which requires a showing that the information
sought was "relevant to an