Two Pending Cases Outline Dilemma
By Stephen W. Feingold
The enactment of the Federal Trademark Dilution Act (Act) (please see endnote 1) in 1996 has highlighted the underlying tension between trademark law as a property right and a method of consumer protection.
Simply stated, if trademarks are property, then their owners are entitled, as are all property owners, to ensure that the value of their property is not unfairly diminished. If, however, trademark rights are a means to ensure that consumers get what they expect (i.e. are not confused), then trademark owners are merely guardians of the public interest.
In the recent decision of Ringling Bros.- Barnum & Bailey Combined Shows Inc. v. Utah Div. Of Travel Dept., (please see endnote 2) the Fourth Circuit held that the Act is far more limited than presumed by most trademark practitioners. The clear motivation underlying Ringling was the desire to ensure that trademark rights do not become rights in gross.