Drawing the line between protected speech and unprotected action
is one of the oldest issues under the First Amendment. Recent cases
involving social media postings are raising the issue once again.
Put simply, these cases ask whether social media posts can function
as such powerful calls to action that they should be treated as
actions, not speech.
In one case, families of victims from the Pulse nightclub
shooting have claimed social media companies bear responsibility
for radicalizing shooter Omar Mateen. In another, a woman was
charged with involuntary manslaughter based on texts she sent
encouraging her boyfriend to commit suicide. These cases are
generally similar to a series of cases around 30 years ago that
targeted Soldier of Fortune magazine for publishing
alleged assassin-for-hire ads. Most of these cases failed due to
policy problems with the negligent publication theories on which
they were based. But one case succeeded, against the ominously
titled book,