About two months ago we wrote the post
Complaints Are Like Onions, They Have Layers about the
need for courts to "address the viability of each claim"
on a motion to dismiss. Bayer Corporation v. Leach, 2020
WL 3118509 at *1 (Ind. S. Ct. Jun. 12, 2020). Complaints need to be
pulled apart and each cause of action and/or theory of liability
needs to be examined – like they layers of an onion. Or to
continue the theme of our prior post, maybe you're more of a
Donkey than an Ogre and you prefer to draw an analogy to parfaits.
After all, "parfaits are delicious" and parfaits have
layers. We certainly aren't going to argue otherwise. But we
think complaints are more like onions – they can stink, they
can make you cry, and if left too long "they start sprouting
little white heads." Well, not literally, but you get the
idea. Onions, ogres, complaints – they all have layers that
require peeling because sometimes you find a layer or two worth
tossing down the garbage disposal.