This week, we ask the question: what happens to a class
action after the defendants win an appeal?
The case posing this question is Glaberson v. Comcast Corp., No.
03-6604, 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 160892 (E.D. Pa. Nov. 12, 2013). And
the facts should be familiar: Glaberson is the current name for the
case the Supreme Court heard as Comcast Corp. v.
Behrend.
After the Supreme Court reversed Behrend, the parties began
litigating the question of what happened to the case next. The
plaintiffs argued that they should have the opportunity to file
another motion for class certification (their third), based on more
specific expert testimony that would model damages based only on
the court-accepted overbuild theory. The defendants argued that if
the Supreme Court had meant to remand the case for further
proceedings, it would have used the word "remand"
somewhere in its order, instead of simply saying that the Third
Circuit's judgment was "reversed."