Two weeks ago, we began our detailed analysis of the data on
oral arguments in civil and criminal cases between 2008 and 2016.
This week and next, we'll be looking at Justice Rita B.
Garman's patterns in oral argument, starting with civil
cases.
Our data includes 102 cases in which Justice Garman voted with a
majority affirming, and 176 in which she joined a majority
reversing. Overall, in affirmances Justice Garman averaged 2.03
questions to appellants and 1.22 questions to appellees (like the
Court as a whole, averaging more questions to the losing party).
Writing the majority opinion had a significant impact, suggesting
that when Justice Garman is quite active at oral argument, she is
likely writing the majority opinion. In affirmances, she averaged
3.73 questions to appellants and 1.73 questions to appellees. There
are only two cases in which she joined a majority affirming and
wrote a concurrence (to eleven where she wrote the majority
opinion). When Justice