For the past few weeks, we've been reviewing the oral
argument data on individual Justices, trying to determine whether
it's possible to predict from the analytics whether a
particular Justice is likely to dissent. This week, we're
looking at the numbers for Chief Justice Burke.
When the Chief Justice is in the majority, we see the expected
patterns. In an affirmance, she averages 2.74 questions to
appellants and 1.24 to appellees. In a reversal, she averages
two questions to appellees and 1.78 to respondents. When she
joins the majority in a split result ("affirmed in part,
reversed in part"), she averages 2.05 questions to appellants
and 1.64 to appellees.
When the Chief Justice dissents in a civil case, the results are
clear – she more heavily questions the appellant regardless
of her own views of the case. When the majority affirms but
she votes to reverse, she averages 1.64 questions to appellants,
0.55 to appellees. When the majority reverses but she