On October 14, 2026, the Third Circuit, sitting en banc for only the second time this year, heard Laureano v. Attorney General, No. 24-2433. The original opinion in Laureano was issued by a split three-judge panel on May 29, 2026, but was later vacated by the Circuit when it granted the United States Attorney General’s petition for a rehearing en banc. Such petitions, though rarely successful, can afford litigants one more bite at the apple without having to proceed via a standard petition for rehearing or a writ of certiorari.
In his dissent to the original decision, Judge Matey commented that he would prefer to “fix the mistakes now without the cost of [an] en banc” rehearing, perhaps anticipating the Circuit’s ultimate decision to vacate the opinion. That prescient comment begs the question – how does the Third Circuit decide to hear matters en banc? Moreover, what should litigants interested in filing such a petition prioritize when drafting? This article addresses both