Christine N. Walz is an Associate in our
Washington, D.C. office.
The D.C. Circuit issued its en banc opinion in
American Meat Institute v. U.S. Department of Agriculture.
The Court agreed with the panel's decision and specifically
held that the test for assessing government mandates requiring
disclosure of "purely factual and uncontroversial
information" is whether the disclosure requirements are
related to a substantial State interest.
The Court held that this standard applies to all substantial
State interests, not only the State interest in correcting
misleading or confusing commercial speech. The Court held
that the interests implicated by the regulation -- including what
the Court referred to as "the demonstrated consumer interest
in extending country-of-origin labeling to food products and the
individual health concerns and market impacts that can arise in the
event of a food-borne illness outbreak"--were substantial.