In a recent decision that could alter how plaintiffs present
expert witness testimony in state court toxic tort claims, the
Georgia Court of Appeals in Sterigenics US LLC v. Mutz,
No. A25A1377, 2025 WL 3041770 (Ga. Ct. App. Oct. 31, 2025),
addresses a core issue in toxic tort litigation: the standards
governing admissibility of expert witness testimony about general
causation.
Plaintiffs in this consolidated set of cases claimed that
exposure to ethylene oxide (EtO), emitted by a Sterigenics
sterilization facility in Cobb County, Georgia, caused cancer or
birth defects to themselves or their children. These eight
bellwether cases were selected for discovery and pretrial motions,
with the key issue focusing on whether plaintiffs' expert
testimony regarding general causation satisfied Georgia Rule 702,
which tracks Federal Rule of Evidence 702.