Class actions, and Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure, have long been rife with controversy. It's safe to
assume that the Seventh Circuit's decision last week in Fonder v. Sheriff of Kankakee Cnty., No.
15-2905 (7th Cir. May 26, 2016), will likely garner mixed
reviews from the bar.
Fonder is a reminder that class certifications are not
set in stone. Judge Easterbrook—who wrote for the court,
joined by Judge Sykes and Judge Adelman from the E.D. Wis., who sat
by designation—held that class definitions must be
revisited when "evidence calls into question the
propriety" of such definitions.
The substantive issue confronted in Fonder stemmed from
a class action filed by three arrestees who objected to the
constitutionality of a jail's written policy to "strip
search" every arrestee before that person entered the general
population. The plaintiffs objected to the policy because it
applied to all arrested persons, even those who had not
yet been brought