This article is part of a series of tributes on the career of
Justice Stephen Breyer.
Deanne E. Maynard is co-chair of Morrison &
Foerster's appellate and Supreme Court practice and a former
assistant to the solicitor general. She clerked for Breyer during
the 1994-95 term.
I had the good fortune to clerk for the justice during his first
term on the Supreme Court. To me, he'll always be Justice
Breyer, the mentor. But I admire other Justice Breyers as well.
The pragmatist. Justice Breyer is ever
conscious that the court's decisions impact real people. So he
considers the practical implications, taking into account not only
the law, but also what makes sense and what is just. He generally
eschews bright-line rules in favor of flexible tests that allow
judges to exercise judgment based on the particulars of a case.
That taught me, as an advocate, to emphasize why the law is on my
client's side and why it should be.