Rule 68 offers of judgment have been
controversial in the class action context. Defendants will often
use them in an attempt to moot the class claims of the named
plaintiff: offering full relief first, and then moving to dismiss
the case on jurisdictional grounds should the plaintiff decline the
offer.
But there is a second, also controversial, use of the offer of
judgment, where the defendant makes the offer as a means of
limiting litigation costs. Under Rule 68(d), if the
defendant makes an offer for a definite amount, the plaintiff
rejects the offer, and then recovers less than the offer, she is
responsible for the costs of litigation subsequent to the
offer.
As Columbia law student Jack Starcher recognizes in his note,
Addressing What Isn't There: How District
Courts Manage the Threat of Rule 68's Cost-Shifting Provision
in the Context of Class Actions, 114 COLUM. L. REV. 129
(2014), this cost-limiting offer of judgment can be a powerful tool
for defendants.