In considering whether a Texas law banning the use of drones for
surveillance purposes violates the First Amendment, a federal judge
sitting in Austin held the law infringes on the right of
journalists to document and disseminate the news.
Background
The Texas statute, enacted in 2015, imposes both civil and
criminal penalties for the use of drones "to capture an image
of an individual or privately owned real property . . . with the
intent to conduct surveillance on the individual or property
captured in the image."
As a result of the law, many Texas journalists, unsure of the
implications of its vague wording, refrained from relying on drones
to gather images and videos for their reporting. For example, a
San Antonio Express News reporter was dissuaded from
relying on his drone after a local police department warned him of
potential criminal penalties. In another example cited by the
Court, an independent journalist's drone images were rejected
by one