In Short
The Situation: The Supreme Court's ruling
in Universal Health Services, Inc. v. U.S. ex rel.
Escobar, 136 S. Ct. 1989 (2016), opened the door to more
materiality defenses under the False Claims Act ("FCA"),
but without making clear when such arguments should succeed.
The Result: In U.S. ex rel. Janssen v.
Lawrence Memorial Hospital, the Tenth Circuit affirmed a grant
of summary judgment on materiality grounds under Escobar
for a theory alleging that the defendant falsified medical records.
The court emphasized that the government continued to pay the
defendant's claims, even after learning of the allegations, and
that the defendant's alleged misconduct was not
"sufficiently widespread."