In Matteson v. Walsh, Case No. 10-P-537, 2011 Mass. App. LEXIS
647 (May 2, 2011), the Appeals Court addressed whether a life
tenant of real property had committed waste, and the appropriate
remedy.
Dorothy Walsh (the "decedent") died in 1987. In her
will, the decedent devised real property in Chatham consisting of a
summer cottage and an unattached garage to her son Robert Walsh
("Walsh") as the life tenant, and thereafter, upon
Walsh's death, to the heirs of Walsh and the decedent's
other two children, Elizabeth Gay Matteson ("Matteson")
and Catherine Baisly ("Baisly"). Walsh resided at the
Chatham property, but he stopped paying taxes in or about 2004,
resulting in the town's issuance of a notice of tax-taking, and
he also stopped paying to maintain the property, causing it to fall
into disrepair. Matteson paid some of the delinquent taxes and
hired someone to repair the premises, which were described as being
in "considerable distress." Eventually, however,