Parties may now seek discovery from district courts within the
Sixth Circuit for use in foreign private arbitrations. In Abdul Latif Jameel Transportation Company v.
FedEx, a unanimous panel held that the plain meaning of
the phrase "foreign or international tribunal" included
non-governmental tribunals. The decision addresses an important
foreign-discovery provision that, according to some at the ABA, had
raised more questions than courts had
answered.
Following a deep dive into dictionaries, treatises, and judicial
precedent, the Sixth Circuit held that a federal district court has
the authority, under 28 U.S.C. § 1782(a), to compel discovery
from a U.S. corporation for use in a foreign private
proceedings—in this case, a Dubai arbitration. The decision
departed from two 1999 precedents of the Second and Fifth Circuits,
which limit discovery to government proceedings. Those opinions,
according to Judge Bush, "turned to legislative history too
early in the