Ordinarily, a civil plaintiff must make his own arrangements to
serve the defendant. But under Rule 4(c)(3) of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure, the district court "may order that service be
made by a United States marshal or deputy marshal or by a person
specially appointed by the court." And where the plaintiff
proceeds in forma pauperis, the court "must so
order."
But sometimes, the Marshals Service's initial efforts to
track down a defendant fail. So it happened in Williams v. Werlinger, No. 14-1376 (Aug.
5, 2015).
Williams sued Werlinger, the former warden at the prison where
Williams was held, for violating his constitutional rights. Because
Williams was approved to file in forma pauperis, the
district court directed the marshals to serve Werlinger. However,
"within days" of the court's order, the marshals
responded that they couldn't serve Werlinger "because he
had retired the previous March and left no forwarding
address."