When a plaintiff alleges complex and overlapping injuries, such
as traumatic brain injury (TBI), psychological trauma, or cognitive
impairment, defendants must have access to the right tools to
fairly evaluate and defend against the claim. In a recent decision,
the Appellate Division, Second Department affirmed a critical
procedural right for defendants: the ability to compel multiple
independent medical examinations (IMEs) when justified by the
nature of the injuries at issue.
In Mazzola v. Claridge's Co., LLC, 2025 NY Slip Op
01918, the court reversed the lower court's denial of a defense
motion to compel an additional IME by a neuropsychologist,
following an earlier IME conducted by a specialist in neurology and
psychiatry. The plaintiff alleged significant psychological and
cognitive injuries. The court emphasized that CPLR 3121(a)does not
limit the number of IMEs a defendant may obtainand that additional
examinations are appropriate when supported by necessity: