On October 28, 2014, the Pa Supreme Court issued one of many
orders in which they denied a Petition For Allowance of Appeal. In
this case, Cordes, v. Associates of Internal
Medicine, the Supreme Court refused to take a case
that was viewed by the Pa Superior Court as a case of first
impression in Pennsylvania. Whether a Judge can rely upon a
prospective jurors statement that they can be fair when there is a
pre-existing relationship between a juror and one of the parties in
the case.
I previously
blogged on the Superior Court decision. In summary the Pa
Superior Court vacated a defense jury verdict since the trial judge
should have struck one or more jurors for cause. The result
of the Pa Supreme Court's refusal to hear the case is that the
case is remanded for a new trial. As I indicated in my
previous post, this was an odd case. Usually, trial judges
are very cautious and will strike jurors for cause if there is a
pre-existing relationship. In this case the